Excerpt: ...y 18, 2021 to provide further information. Supplemental supporting documents were submitted on February 16, 2021 only 2 days before the hearing. Plaintiff has addressed a majority of the deficiencies noted by the court in its January 7, 2021 ruling. The court's remaining concerns are as follows: Plaintiff has provided information as requested about the net settlement and estimated distribution to class members. The estimated average distribution ...

Excerpt: ... from Defendant's negligence in permitting an unrestrained dog to chase Plaintiff giving rise to fear of an attack which caused Plaintiff to fall and suffer injuries. This is Plaintiff's second effort seeking summary judgment. Her first motion was denied on February 13, 2020 almost a year prior to the current hearing. Defendant points out a myriad of procedural deficiencies in the moving papers, the majority of which are valid. The court, however...

Excerpt: ...serts Plaintiffs are required to arbitrate even though one of them is not a signatory to the agreement containing the arbitration clause under Felisilda v. FCA US LLC (2020) 53 Cal.App.5 th 486. Plaintiff asserts the case is not applicable because Plaintiff has dismissed all claims against the dealer and is pursuing only the manufacturer. At least one federal court agrees with Plaintiff's contention that Felisilda does not apply when pursuing onl...

Excerpt: ...Plaintiff's Motion to Tax Costs. Defendant seeks monetary sanctions asserting Plaintiff continued to pursue frivolous pleadings after being advised that Plaintiff intended to seek sanctions for such conduct under CCP 128.7. The court finds Defendant's notice of the hearing on its motion for sanctions was statutorily compliant. Plaintiff's attempt to assert the motion was fatally deficient because the motion was heard on January 14, 2021 rather th...

Excerpt: ... at 8:30 a.m. in Department 1. On August 27, 2020, the court granted preliminary approval of the class settlement entered between Plaintiffs and Defendants. The declaration from the settlement administrator shows that notice of the settlement was provided to 474 class members by mail on October 19, 2020. Twenty-nine notices were ultimately undeliverable. No requests for exclusion from the class were received. No objections to the settlement were ...

Excerpt: ...r Costs and Attorneys' Fees as Prevailing Party on Appeal and to Order that Defendant recover costs on appeal in the sum of $820.70; and (2) to Grant the Motion by Plaintiff to Strike/Tax Memorandum of Costs on Appeal Submitted by Defendant D.L. Walton Engineering and to Order the claim for attorneys' fees stricken from Defendant's Memorandum of Costs on Appeal. Plaintiff obtained judgment against Defendant by default. Defendant moved in this cou...

Excerpt: ...material, triable issues of fact exist are to be resolved in favor of the party opposing summary judgment. . .. A defendant moving for summary judgment meets its burden of showing that there is no merit to a cause of action if that party has shown that one or more elements of the cause of action cannot be established or that there is a complete defense to that cause of action. (§ 437c, subds. (o)(2), (p)(2).) If the defendant does so, the burden...

Excerpt: ...vised that Plaintiff intended to seek sanctions for such conduct under CCP 128.7. Defendant asserts Plaintiff's pleadings in this action were both factually frivolous and legally frivolous. Defendant seeks monetary sanctions in the sum of $8,757.00. Defendant asserts the amount represents reasonable attorneys' fees and costs incurred since the notice required under CCP 128.7 was given. Defendant's Request for Judicial Notice is granted. Plaintiff...

Excerpt: ...otion and initial declaration a second time. Insufficient information has been submitted as to various provisions of the settlement agreement for the court to make the merits evaluation required by Kullar v. Foot Locker Retail, Inc. (2008) 168 Cal.App.4th 116, 129. 1. Sufficiency of Amount of Settlement ($750,000) The gross settlement amount is $750.000. Plaintiff estimates the total number of class members is proximately 2400. Plaintiff provides...

Excerpt: ...ees, costs, and expenses. This award of attorney fees is based on lodestar attorney fees of $53,600.00 plus a lodestar multiplier of 0.5 for the Knight Law Group and a lodestar of $2,950.00 plus a lodestar multiplier of 0.5 for the law firm of Robinson Calcagnie, Inc. Plaintiffs shall also recover their costs incurred in the amount of $12,396.90 subject to defendant's motion to tax costs that will be heard on January 21, 2021. The Song-Beverly Co...

Excerpt: ...thurton's first amended complaint. Defendant General Motors LLC's shall file its answer to the plaintiff Arthurton's first amended complaint within ten (10) days of this ruling. General Motors LLC's demurrer to Mr. Arthurton's first amended complaint In this action, Mr. Arthurton asserts causes of action for breach of implied warranty of merchantability under the Song-Beverly Warranty Act, breach of express warranty under the Song- Beverly Warran...

Excerpt: ...Complaint. (2) To Grant the Application of Michael A. Graziano to Appear as Counsel Pro Hac Vice. (1) Plaintiff asserts Defendant breached its account holder agreement by charging two fees during a single use of a third party automated teller machine – $1.50 for withdrawing funds and $1.00 to check the account balance. Plaintiff alleges only one fee is authorized under the agreement. Plaintiff asserts claims both individually and as representat...

Excerpt: ...low. Plaintiffs should not submit the entire motion and initial declarations a second time. Insufficient information has been submitted as to various provisions of the settlement agreement for the court to make the merits evaluation required by Kullar v. Foot Locker Retail, Inc. (2008) 168 Cal.App.4th 116, 129. 1. Sufficiency of Amount of Settlement ($2,000,000.00) The gross settlement amount is a figure not to exceed $2,000,000 Plaintiff estimat...

Excerpt: ... the alternative to deem matters admitted; (2) To grant in part and deny in part plaintiff Harriet Armstead's Motion to Compel Special Interrogatories, Set Two Plaintiff Harriet Armstead's Motion to Compel Responses, or in the Alternative to Deem Matters Admitted This is a personal injury case that arises out of an April 20, 2019 confrontation between plaintiff and a dog owned by defendant Tamara Lagomarsino. Plaintiff contends that she fell and ...

Excerpt: ...tiffs' Complaint. Defendant mailed a form of judgment to Plaintiffs on September 9, 2020. The court signed the form of judgment on September 30, 3020 and judgment was filed the same day. Plaintiff now asserts they attempted to appear at trial via Zoom, but were unable to do so. The court normally only allows Zoom trial appearances by stipulation, which, in this case, the plaintiff had neither sought nor received. As will be detailed below, this c...

Excerpt: ...e to conduct this interview All parties were given proper notice of this matter. There has been no response to this motion. Defendant Allan moves this court for an order that compels plaintiff Angela Reynoso to submit to a clinical interview to evaluate the nature and extent of any physical injuries she sustained as the result of a traumatic brain injury that she attributes to the accident at issue in this case. The court notes that defendants ha...

Excerpt: ... a personal care attendant for Patricia Kline. In October 2020, Patricia Kline passed away. Defendant Gerald Kline remains in possession of the premises despite the plaintiff's demand that Mr. Kline vacate. Plaintiff has requested confirmation of Ms. Kline's date of death and a copy of her death certificate. But to date, the Kline family has not provided any evidence that Ms. Kline has indeed passed away. Moreover, plaintiff conducted an internet...

Excerpt: ... medical negligence. In the original complaint the only named defendant was Kaweah Health Care District. The “Doe” defendants 1-25 were named as fictitious names and plaintiff contended that he could not identify the true names of these Doe defendants when he filed his original complaint. On November 15, 2019, plaintiff served a “Notice of Intention to Commence Suit” that identified both Optimal Health Services and Optimal Home Health Car...

Excerpt: ..., the parties entered into a Settlement Agreement that obligated defendant to pay $10,000.00 to plaintiff in monthly payments of $200.00. These monthly payments were to begin on September 15, 2020. Plaintiff's counsel Adam B. Stirrup states in his declaration that defendant has not paid any of the monthly payments. No opposition to the motion has been filed. The terms of this settlement were memorized in a February 28, 2020 “Settlement Agreemen...

Excerpt: ...ng out of a credit card obligation where plaintiff Capital One Bank pleads causes of action for breach of contract and common counts. On February 5, 2019, the parties entered into a Settlement Agreement that obligated defendant to pay $12,040.11 to plaintiff in monthly payments of $325.00 beginning on the 16th day of every month until the debt has been paid in full. This settlement agreement reserved the right to plaintiff to move the court under...

Excerpt: ...urther the construction of the State's high speed rail project. Negotiations between the parties resulted in a stipulation and order that the court entered on January 28, 2020. This stipulated order imposed a duty on the parties to cooperate and collaborate and undertake the necessary steps required to enable the State of California to acquire the portion of the defendant's property that it seeks to obtain. The State contends the defendant has no...

Excerpt: ...mand for production of documents. Claimant Ricky Lynn Serrate shall provide full and complete verified responses to these interrogatories and document requests without objection within thirty days from notice of this ruling. Claimant Ricky Lynn Serrate shall also pay monetary sanctions to AAA's counsel in the amount of $472.50 within thirty days from the notice of this ruling. The Court notes that these discovery motions were timely noticed and s...

Excerpt: ...ntiff shall provide full and complete verified responses to these discovery requests without objection to defendant's counsel later than 20 days from the date of notice of this ruling. Mr. Souza and his counsel shall also pay monetary sanctions to defendant's counsel in the amount of $560.00 no later than 30 days from the date of notice of this ruling as per CCP §2023.030 (a) and CCP §2030.290(c) The Court notes that these discovery motions wer...

Excerpt: ...adjudication were separately filed in each case. On November 22, 2020 the court entered its order consolidating the cases for purposes of summary adjudication. The subject motions arise out of two separate actions arising out of the treatment of John Torrez III. The first action (VCU268786) was a medical negligence claim and included a loss of consortium claim by spouse Bernadette Torrez. The action was filed in March 2017 and alleged damages fro...

Excerpt: ...No. VCU276661 filed December 18, 2018. The prior action was not served until Plaintiff filed its First Amended Complaint on July 31, 2019. The prior action was brought by the City of Corcoran against Curtimade Dairy asserting causes of action for public nuisance, trespass, negligence, and unlawful business practices. Both the prior action and the subject action involve disputes between the parties over alleged contamination of city water wells fr...