Excerpt: ...ages” requested for the Ninth Cause of Action in the Prayer for Relief on page 14 of the F AC. P RO CED URAL H ISTO RY Plaintiff commenced this suit to recover repair and replacement costs from named defendants regarding fire sprinkler sensors that Plaintiff installed but did not own. Plaintiff purchased the sprinkler sensors from defendant Pace Supply C o r p . (“P a c e ”) t o in stall them into the residential homes. The specific model w...

Excerpt: ...) for settlement. Plaintiffs had sued Defendants for motor vehicle property damage and personal injury. ANALYSIS Legal Standard C.C.P. section 877.6 allows a plaintiff to settle with one or more joint tortfeasors without releasing others as long as the settlement is in “good faith.” A good-faith settlement discharges the settling defendant from liability to other parties for equit able contribution or comparative indemnity. ( City of Grand Te...

Excerpt: ...ff filed suit on May 6, 2022, and s erved the summons and complaint upon Defendant through substituted service on May 13, 2023. Defendant did not file a response, so Plaintiff filed a Request for Entry of Default, which the Court entered on July 12, 2023. On July 18, 2023, Defendant's representative from Phoenix Law contacted Plaintiff's counsel wanting to settle the matter on behalf of Defendant. As proof of representation, Phoenix Law emailed a...

Excerpt: ...Plaintiff's complaint alleges that in or around January 2016, Defendant hired Plaintiff to work as a full -time, non- exempt ceiling and acoustical foreman. Plaintiff alleges that he was wrongfully terminated on or about August 12, 2022. Plaintiff alleges that, previously, on April 1, 2022, he injured his right arm while performing job duties. The injury impaired major life activities and constituted a disability. The injury required surgery whic...

Excerpt: ...rling commenced this action to obtain money owed by Arrowtown for roofing work done and for materials provided by Sterling in connection to a construction project on a residential remodeling in Sonoma for Heather Jordan and Joseph Beare (the “Owners”). Arrowtown, as the general contractor, sought a contract with Sterling for roofing work. Arrowtown disputes any additional amounts claimed by Sterling. Sterling submitted a bid proposal for $82,...

Excerpt: ...efendant Bethany Zoe (“Zoe”) stipulated to a settlement agreement in open court. The parties exchanged multiple versions to memorialize this settlement agreement in writing, but Defendants did not agree to the terms because they did not include the requirement for escrow, a title report, and a transfer disclosure statement re garding re al prope rt y at issue . Anabi's posit ion is t hat t he se t e rms we re a part of the general category po...

Excerpt: ...for ju d ic ia l n o t ic e a r e GRAN TED . Defendants shall file and serve their proposed amended answer within 10 days of service of the notice of entry of this order. P RO CED URAL H ISTO RY Plaintiffs brought this action to seek damages from Defendants for breach of contract and property damage arising out of a commercial lease. Defendants filed an unverified answer with a general denial to the verified complaint to avoid an entry of default...

Excerpt: ... located at 4723 Muirfield Court, Santa Rosa, (the “Property”). Defendants were uncertain whether Plaintiff got a permit to install this first. The parties entered into the Settlement Agreement on November 1, 2023. Paragraph 9 of the Settlement Agreement required Plaintiff to provide support that he obtained a permit for the installation of the propane tank. (Declaration of Pavone, Ex hibit A.) Plaintiff had to send this support to Defendant ...

Excerpt: ...a n a g e r if s h e r e lo c a t e d f r o m H a w a ii t o Ca lif o r n ia . P la in t if f w a s liv in g in Hawaii after retiring after working for Defendants for many years, and taking care o f h e r ill husband who requires kidney dialysis. Plaintiff claims she agreed to relocate based on the oral promise that she would be appointed as Store Manager and Defendants would cover her relocation costs. After she had relocated, Defendants offered...

Excerpt: ... a r b it r a t io n . P RO CED URAL H ISTO RY Plaintiff Robert Kourik brought this action against Kaiser and other defendants for medical malpractice after he ended up having severe functional issues, nerve damage, and chronic following a shoulder surgery. Plaintiff was enrolled as a “Senior Advantage ” member of Kaiser for Medicare healthcare benefits. The agreement for Senior Advantage membership included an arbitration provision. The prov...

Excerpt: ...ction against Morales to collect payment on credit card debt he owed. The parties entered into a Stipulation for Entry of Judgment and Settlement and Release and Dismissal (the “Stipulation”), according to which Morales agreed to pay Wells Fargo $10,774.29 to satisfy the debt. (Declaration of Mulhorn, Exhibit 1.) He agreed to make an initial payment of $1,114.29, followed by monthly payments of $420.00 until he satisfied the debt. (Motion, 3:...

Excerpt: ...en the weather was rainy and muddy. (Motion, 3:3 -5 .) Th e h o rs e , Rush, bucked while Plaintiff was mounted upon him. Plaintiff argues Defendant Fricke, Plaintiff's trainer, ran up behind him which caused him to react and P la in t if f t o f a ll, w h ile D e f e n d a n t s c la im P la in t if f a lr e a d y f e ll o f f t h e h o r s e b e f o r e Defendant Fricke ran up to her. Be f o r e c o m m e n c in g r id in g le s s o n s , P la ...

Excerpt: ...remodel and renovation of property owned by Owners, for which project ACI was hired as the general contractor. (Motion, 2:2 -5 . ) AC I s o lic it e d r o o f in g w o r k f r o m P la in t if f St e r lin g Ro o f in g In c . (“St e r lin g ”) a n d O w n e r s selected and a pproved roofing materials to be installed at their home for the remodeling and renovation. ( Id . at 2:4-9.) After the completion of work, Sterling demanded additional ...

Excerpt: ...ilding, grading, and zoning code violations related to unpermitted greenhouses, solar arrays and cannabis cultivation on their property. (See Complaint, 1:19- 27.) In the Defendants' amended answer, they plead various affirmative defenses and they denied or admitted each allegation in the complaint or otherwise stated they did not have enough information to admit or deny it, so denied it. (See g enerally, Amended Answer.) Finding issue with the A...

Excerpt: ...Afterwards she filed her complaint in this matter seeking damages from Walmart for negligence and p r e m is e s lia b ilit y. ( Ib id .) Walmart has moved for summary judgment as to these causes of action and Plaintiff has opposed. AN ALYSIS Legal Standard Motion for Summary Judgment Summary judgment “shall be granted if all the papers submitted show that there is no triable issue as to any material fact and that the moving party is entitled t...

Excerpt: ...warded only as to the $60.00 filing fee. Defendants shall provide complete, objection -free verified responses to Plaintiff, and pay $60.00 in sanctions within 30 days of service of the notice of e nt ry of orde r. Proce dural Hist ory Plaintiff propounded post -judgment written interrogatories and demands for production on Defendants and Defendants never responded, despite Plaintiff's efforts to meet and confer on the lack of response. Plaintiff...

Excerpt: ...s action arose from a contract for purchase and sale of real property between the Wights and the Richardsons. (Cross -Co m p la in t , ¶ 1 0 .) The Wights claim the Richardsons misrepresented the details of the metes and bounds of the property sold. ( Ib id .) The Richardsons claim that they advised the Wights of errors in the legal description after the sale and applied to the Sonoma County Permit & Resource Management Department to correct the...

Excerpt: ...d motor vehicle negligence after she was injured in a motor vehicle collision between her vehicle/ trailer and another vehicle. (Motion, 1:26 -28, 2:1- 3.) Sonoma propounded set one of form int errogatories and requests for production on Jones, but she has failed to ever respond despite Sonoma's meet and confer efforts regarding the discovery requests. ( Id . at 3:7-28, 4:1- 11.) Jones' counsel was relieved as counsel because there was a breakdow...

Excerpt: ...Zoe moved for summary judgment on claims brought against her in the cross -c o m p la in t . ( Id . a t 2 :2 -12.) This Court issued an order after hearing on the motion granting Zoe's motion for summary adjudication (the “Order”) because Cross -Complainants lacked essential elements to all of the causes of action as to Zoe. (See generally, Orde r Aft e r He a ring on Cross-Defendant Bethany Zoe's Motion for Summary Adjudication of the Cross ...

Excerpt: ...tices; 4. Appointing Plaintiffs as Class Representatives for settlement purposes; 5. Appointing Plaintiffs' Counsel, Justin F. Marquez and Benjamin H. Haber of Wilshire Law Firm, PLC, as Class Counsel for settlement purposes; 6. Ap p o in t in g Sim p lu r is Cla s s Ac t io n Se t t le m e n t Ad m in is t r a t io n a s t h e Settlement Administrator; and 7. Scheduling a Final Approval Hearing. P r e lim in a r y a p p r o v a l is GRAN TED . T...

Excerpt: ...fects and nonconformities to warranty regarding Plaintiff's 2019 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 (“Subject Vehicle”). (Motion, 3:2- 1 3 . ) Plaintiff served GM with a notice of deposition of its PMQ with a demand for document production. ( Id . at 3:14-22.) The topics for examination included: (1) G M 's p r e -lit ig a t io n a n a ly s is a s t o w h e t h e r t h e 2 0 1 9 Ch e v r o le t Silv e r a d o 1 5 0 0 should be repurchased; (2) all repa...

Excerpt: ...e was a minor. (Motion, 1:21-25. ) After Defendant Roman Catholic Bishop of Santa Rosa filed for bankruptcy protection, a case management conference was set in this matter for June 1, 2023, which Plaintiff failed to appear at because Plaintiff's counsel failed to calendar the hearing. ( Id . at 1:26- 28, 2:1-2.) The Court set an Order to Show Cause hearing for July 13, 2023, for which Plaintiff's counsel filed a case management statement, but fai...

Excerpt: ...M o t io n , 2 : 5 -10.) The jury also awarded attorney's fees plus prejudgment interest an d punitive damages. ( Id . at 2:11-1 6 .) P la in t if f n o w seeks prejudgment interest per Civil Code 3287(a) for the total amount of $666,075.01 against Defendant. ( Id . at 2:17-18.) EVID EN TIARY O BJ ECTIO N S “All written objections to evidence must be served and filed separately from the other papers in support of or in opposition to the motion....

Excerpt: ...��P la in t if f ”) b r o u g h t t h is a c t io n a g a in s t Defendant for violations of Sonoma County Municipal Code Chapter 13 Section 1, private nuisance, and public nuisance, after Defendant cleared a certain number of dead and dyi ng trees that had been burned during the Tubbs fire through Defendant's lands pursuant to the directions from California's Department of Forestry and local officials. (Motion, 2:15 -2 4 .) Ultimately, without...

Excerpt: ...(Motion, 1:2-4.) The sales contract Plaintiff entered into with Bone contained an arbitration provision covering claims that arose out of the purchase or condition of the Nissan Rogue. (Id. at 1:9-13.) Plaintiff and Bone were signatories of the sales contract but not Nissan, and the contract expressly applied to Bone and its agents. (Ibid.) The relevant portions of the arbitration provisions read as follows: “You agree to the terms of this cont...

Excerpt: ...2 and 2572 ½ Bodega Avenue, Petaluma, California (APN 021-041- 025) (the “Subject Property”). (Undisputed Material Fact [“UMF”], ¶ 1.) The parties dispute the size of the Subject Property. Mendonca says it is ½ acre. Linsenmeyer claims it is larger. Both agree it is improved by a main residence and accessory dwelling unit (“Unit 2572 ½”). (Ibid.) The parties inherited the Subject Property from Mendonca's father Johnnie Lear (“Le...

Excerpt: ...tion-free verified responses to Plaintiff, and pay $60.00 in sanctions within 30 days of service of the notice of entry of order. Procedural History This Court previously entered a default judgment against Defendants. Afterwards, Plaintiff propounded written interrogatories and demands for production on Defendants, and Defendants never responded, despite Plaintiff's follow-up correspondence to meet and confer on the lack of response. Plaintiff br...

Excerpt: ... Two, Nos. 34, 36, and 43. The motions are DENIED as to all other discovery. Jacoby requested sanctions of $13,050.00 against Defendant. Sanctions are partially GRANTED for the reduced amount of $6,525.00. Procedural History Jacoby commenced this wage and hour class action against Defendant for alleged violations of various Labor Codes. (Motion to Compel Further Responses re Production Requests [“MTCFR PROD”], 3:25-27.) Jacoby served set one ...

Excerpt: ...n or in her counsel's declaration. Nellessen simultaneously moves to compel the deposition of Defendant's person most knowledgeable (“PMK”) and requests leave to reopen discovery. The Court GRANTS leave to reopen discovery and also the motion to compel the deposition of Defendant's PMK. Procedural History Defendant served Nellessen's counsel with the five depositions subpoena production of business records on the Subpoenaed Entities and notic...

Excerpt: ...Sonoma County but does have an office in San Francisco and that, according to Revenue and Taxation Code (“RTC”) section 6933, venue is proper only in a county where the Attorney General maintains an office. There is no opposition to the motion. When a party contends that an action has been brought in the wrong court, i.e., that venue is not proper in the court in which the action has been brought, the party may move to transfer venue to a pro...

Excerpt: ...ng to pay the amount owed. Plaintiff filed this action to collect the debt, allegedly $15,795.66, plus costs, legal fees, and interest. Defendants failed to appear, so Plaintiff obtained their default on May 25, 2023, and obtained a default judgment against them on June 23, 2023 for $20,425.41. Post-Judgment Discovery Plaintiff served Defendants by mail with post-judgment discovery on July 25, 2023; the discovery included one set of production de...

Excerpt: ...verages but that although Youngs performed, Defendants breached the contract by failing to pay the amount owed. Plaintiff filed this action to collect the debt, allegedly $6,381.54, plus costs, legal fees, and interest. Defendants failed to appear, so Plaintiff obtained their default on November 16, 2021, and obtained a default judgment against them on January 12, 2022 for $9,249.34. Post-Judgment Discovery Plaintiff served Defendants by mail wit...

Excerpt: ... pay Plaintiff the full amount owed after Plaintiff suffered a loss (the “Loss”) to the Property. Motion Defendant moves the court for a protective order shielding it from the burden and expense of responding to Plaintiff First Set of Requests for Admission (“RFAs”), First Set of Requests for Production (“RFPs”), and First Set of Special Interrogatories (collectively, the “Discovery”). Alternatively, it asks the court to extend th...

Excerpt: ... to take her son out of a car which Defendant was driving. Only one Plaintiff, Jeanine Grider (“Plaintiff” or “Jeanine”) is identified as a party, and she is self-represented, but the FAC appears to assert claims on behalf of minor son, William Grider (“William”). Defendant answered the FAC and later brought a special motion to strike the sixth cause of action pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure section 425.16. The court granted that ...

Excerpt: ...y premiums, but Defendant failed to pay premiums owed. It seeks to collect the unpaid premiums. Plaintiff filed this action on June 26, 2023. It later filed a proof of service for the summons and complaint on September 6, 2023, purporting to show service on Defendant personally on August 2, 2023, at 3:39 p.m.at 689 Benicia Drive, santa Rosa, CA 95409. Defendant failed to appear, so Plaintiff obtained Defendant's default on September 26, 2023. Pla...

Excerpt: ... issuing water well permits for groundwater extraction; and adopt and implement policies and procedures to ensure consideration of the impacts of water well permits on public trust resources and uses and also to prevent harm from the impacts of such permits. Petitoners set forth two identified causes of action, both seeking a writ of mandate: 1) Violation of CECA, and 2) Failure to Comply With Mandatory Duties Under the Public Trust Doctrine. In ...

Excerpt: ...efendants have trespassed on Plaintiff's Property. Plaintiff subsequently obtained a temporary restraining order ("TRO") and then a preliminary injunction (the "Injunction") against Defendant Mona Verducci ("Mona") in February 2023. The Injunction orders Mona and her agents or others not to enter upon Plaintiff's Property as defined by the survey (the "Survey") attached as Exhibit A to the Injunction. Plaintiff then brought an application for ord...

Excerpt: ...ng attempting to sell a portion of his general partner interest (the "GP Interest") to Kelly. As a result of developments during this litigation, including Defendat' efforts to sell an important Partnership asset, real property comprising the Summerfield Shopping Center (the "Property"), he ultimately filed a second amended complaint ("SAC") which includes, amongst others, claims for wrongdoing based on Defendants' efforts to sell the Property. M...

Excerpt: ...daughter Vanessa French ("Decedent"), negligently caused Decedent's death. They allege that Decedent sought medical care from Defendants for a combination of physical and emotional complaints which included skin conditions, back pack, severe depression, and suicidal ideations, but that Defendants negligently failed to provide proper treatment, resulting in Decedent handing herself. Plaintiff Wendy French ("Wendy" or "Mother Plaintiff"), individua...

Excerpt: ...s Brian Williams, Jamie Williams, and Brian Tiewater (collectively, the "Individual Defendants") but fail to allege how they are involved. Motion Defendants move for summary judgment or, alternatively, summary adjudication of Plaintiffs' claims. For summary adjudication, they present five issues: 1) Plaintiffs expressly assumed the risks inherent in wrestling; 2) Plaintiffs impliedly assumed the risks inherent in wrestling; 3) Defendants are immu...

Excerpt: .... ("Garton") through an installment sales contract (the "Contract") requiring Defendant to make periodic installment payments and giving Garton a security interest in the Tractor. Garton then allegedly assigned and transferred its interest in the Contract and Tractor to Plaintiff. Plaintiff complains that Defendant has failed to maintain required insurance on the Tractor or make required installment payments, allowing Plaintiff to take possession...

Excerpt: ...san Rogue (the "Car"), which a Defendant had manufactured, the Car is defective, and Defendants have breached the Warranty Contract and failed to comply with warranties for the Car. He attaches a copy of the Warranty Contract as Exhibit A to the complaint, and this shows that it includes a set of warranties from Defendant Nissan North America, lnc ("Nissan"). He alleges that Nissan designs, manufactures, and distributes automobiles while Defendan...

Excerpt: ...ff complains that he leased and then bought a new 2019 Kia Niro (the "Car"), with included warranties, but the Car was defective and subject to safety recalls and Defendants failed to repair or replace or repurchase the Car, and have in fact taken possession of it, preventing Plaintiff from obtaining it or his other personal property in it. He alleges that he leased and purchased the Car from Defendant Jim Bone Kia of Santa Rosa ("Bone"), the aut...

Excerpt: ... except Defendants Douglas Oakes and Margert E. Oakes (the "Oakeses"), specifically, Johnathan Scott Kerson; Jana Harrison; Gregory J. Conklin and Michiko Y. Conklin, in their capacities as trustees of the Conklin Living Trust dated September 4, 1998; John Merline; Sophie Phelps; Dennis J. Pistone; Nancy Pistone; Patrick Boniface Pinney, Sr. and Patric:ia Lou Pinney, in their capacities as trustees of the Troy and Ricky Trust dated July 2 1 , 201...

Excerpt: ...dez had previously sexually assaulted another female patient, Jane Doe ("Doe"), and that Hospital knew or should have known of this conduct yet took no measures regarding it. Plaintiff claims that the wrongdoing occurred when she was in the care of Defendants for hip-replacement surgery. Plaintiff filed this action on September 12, 2022, and, after Defendants answered, entered into a stipulation to file the FAC in order to correct the name of Def...

Excerpt: ...ey allege that after leg surgery, she was admitted to Defendant Summerfield Healthcare Center ("SHC") for recovery, but Defendants' conduct resulted in her developing a Stage Ill pressure ulcer. Decedent was then transferred to Defendant Healdsburg Senior Living Community ("HSLC") where Defendants allowed the wound to worsen, resulting ultimately in her death. Plaintiffs originally named as Defendants Ensign Santa Rosa, LLC dba Summerfield Health...

Excerpt: ...ing that he owns real property at 29 Old Creek Road, Petaluma, California (the "Property"), complains that Defendant has attempted to foreclose on a deed of trust (the "DOT") recorded against the Property securing a loan (the "loan"), in violation of applicable guidelines regarding loan modification and forbearance, and requirements for a single point of contact ("SPOC"). He asserts that Defendant's conduct violated Civil Code ("CC") sections 292...

Excerpt: ... failed to act with due process and have failed to demonstrate that his alleged misconduct is related to the practice of medicine or puts health and safety of others at risk. He also raises other allegations regarding lack of authority or jurisdiction and the need for an oath of allegiance or "fidelity bond," claiming that "Respondents," specifically William Prasifta as Executive Director of the Medical Board of California and deputy attorney gen...

Excerpt: ...oject") belonging to Real Party in Interest Safeway, Inc. ("RPI") at the corner of South McDowell Blvd and Maria Drive, which the city council ("Council") of Respondent City of Petaluma ("Respondent") approved at a final hearing on April 1, 2019, reversing a prior vote of December 3, 2018. Respondent's Planning Commission ("Commission") had approved a CEQA mitigated negative declaration ("MND") and Site Plan and Architectural Review ("SPAR") for ...

Excerpt: ...ppen without taking appropriate measures to stop it or report it. She alleges that she was 59 years old at the time she filed the complaint. She further asserts that the complaint is timely pursuant to Code of Civ-l Procedure ("CCP") section 340.1, which became effective on January 1, 2020, because the achon is for recovery of damages suffered as a result of childhood sexual assault and she filed the action prior to December 31, 2022. She also as...