Excerpt: ... Proc. ("CCP") S 1280 et seq. (the "CAA"). The Motion is GRANTED. The Basis for the Motion Plaintiff offered construction services to Defendants Gaebler and Steinberg under a construction contract. See FAC, Exhibit A (the "Contract"). The Contract contains an arbitration provision covering "any claim arising out of or relating to this contract". See Contract, pg. 9. The Contract was signed by all parties. Governing Law A party seeking to compel a...

Excerpt: ...oject") belonging to Real Party in Interest Safeway, Inc. ("RPI") at the corner of South McDowell Blvd and Maria Drive, which the city council ("Council") of Respondent City of Petaluma ("Respondent") approved at a final hearing on April 1, 2019, reversing a prior vote of December 3, 2018. Respondent's Planning Commission ("Commission") had approved a CEQA mitigated negative declaration ("MND") and Site Plan and Architectural Review ("SPAR") for ...

Excerpt: ...ppen without taking appropriate measures to stop it or report it. She alleges that she was 59 years old at the time she filed the complaint. She further asserts that the complaint is timely pursuant to Code of Civ-l Procedure ("CCP") section 340.1, which became effective on January 1, 2020, because the achon is for recovery of damages suffered as a result of childhood sexual assault and she filed the action prior to December 31, 2022. She also as...

Excerpt: ... Hospital ("Hospital") and Signature Healthcare Services, LLC ("Signature")(together "Defendants" or "Employer") failed to pay members of the Class for work performed, and that Class members skipped or delayed taking meal and rest periods due to understaffing by Employer and that Employer did not pay meal and rest break premiums. Plaintiff alleges that she was regularly in charge of far more patients than allowed by law and that Employer relied h...

Excerpt: ...having been filed, the motion is granted to the extent that this court finds plaintiff Natsios is entitled to partition of the Property by its sale. The court takes judicial notice of the Judgment by Stipulation filed on March 30, 2022, in the Marin County Superior Court, CIV-2003458, Natsios v. Neilsen ("Judgment"). The Judgment states it is entered in favor of plaintiff Manny Natsios ("Natsios") on his cause of achon related to 191 Butterfield ...

Excerpt: ...d by the defense in support of the motion is so scant that it fails to provide the Court with a full picture of the circumstances. An example of this includes the excerpts of Plaintiff's deposition provided in Exhibit F of Defendant's Index of Exhibits. While it is true that a party need not provide the Court with an entire deposition transcript, a party should not solely provide the Court with excerpts that include testimony that is most favorab...

Excerpt: ... file a cross-complaint. They argue the court should use its discretion to deny the motion. At any time during the course of the lawsuit, the court retains power to permit defendant to file or amend a cross-complaint to avoid forfeiture of defendant's "related" claim. Indeed, the court "shall grant" leave as long as defendant is acting in good faith. (CCP S 425.50.) As section 426.50 does not apply as between defendants, the cross-complaint is no...

Excerpt: ...ry Plaintiff's SAC asserts four causes of action for: (1) Discriminaton Based on Sex in Violation of FEHA; (2) Hostile Environment Harassment in Violation of FEHA; (3) Retaliation in Violation of FEHA; and (4) Failure to Prevent in Violation of FEHA. (SAC, 7-21.) These causes of action are brought due to events that occurred while she worked as a volunteer firefighter for Defendant. (Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of MS] ["MSJ MP...

Excerpt: ...ing appropriate measures to stop it or report it. She alleges that she was 59 years old at the time she filed the complaint. She further asserts that the complaint is timely pursuant to Code of Civ-l Procedure ("CCP") section 340.1, which became effective on January 1, 2020, because the achon is for recovery of damages suffered as a result of childhood sexual assault and she filed the action prior to December 31, 2022. She also asserts that the c...

Excerpt: ...laintiff's neighbor, Defendant, and Defendant's boyfriend, Steven Knuttel, moved portions of a fence that had been on the boundary line between their two properties and moved it over onto Plaintiff's property to add space to Defendant's yard for the addition of an ADLI. In building the ADLI, Plaintiff alleges that Mr. Knuttel damaged Plaintiff's fence, removed Plaintiff's landscaping, and damaged Plaintiff's drip system. She also alleges that fen...

Excerpt: ...oject") belonging to Real Party in Interest Safeway, Inc. ("RPI") at the corner of South McDowell Blvd and Maria Drive, which the city council ("Council") of Respondent City of Petaluma ("Respondent") approved at a final hearing on April 1, 2019, reversing a prior vote of December 3, 2018. Respondent's Planning Commission ("Commission") had approved a CEQA mitigated negative declaration ("MND") and Site Plan and Architectural Review ("SPAR") for ...

Excerpt: ... Air Commercial Real Estate Association Standard Industrial/commercial Single-Tenant Lease agreement (the "Lease"). This matter is on calendar for the motion by Schaefer and Scoble ("Amending Parties") pursuant to Cal. Code Civ. Proc. ("CCP") S 473 for leave to amend the Cross-complaint ("SCC"). The motion is opposed by Pearson and PPI ("Opposing Parties"). The Motion is DENIED. Facts and Procedure The original complaint in this action was filed ...

Excerpt: ...intiff brought a Complaint for compensatory and Punitive Damages asserting seven causes of action against her ex-husband, Defendant, alleging he committed acts of domestic violence and sexual assault against her throughout the duration of their marriage. Defendant attempted to meet and confer with Plaintiff as to the third, fourth, and fifth causes of action in Plaintiff's Complaint finding them to be without merit via telephone on two dates in M...

Excerpt: ...rom Defendant under CCP SS 708.030 & 2031.3(1). The unopposed Motion is GRANTED. Defendants shall serve verified code-compliant responses free of objections within thirty (30) days of notice of entry of the order on this Moton. Defendants shall pay $60 in sanctions to Plaintiff within thirty (30) days of notice of entry of the order on this Motion. Governing Law A judgment creditor generally has the same rights to propound discovery to the judgme...

Excerpt: ...oduction of documents ("RPODs") from Defendant under CCP SS 708.030 & 2031.300. The unopposed Motion is GRANTED. Defendants shall serve verified responses free of objections within thirty (30) days of notce of entry of the order on this Motion. Defendants shall pay $50 in sanctions to Plaintiff within thirty (30) days of notce of entry of the order on this Motion. Governing Law A judgment creditor generally has the same rights to propound discove...

Excerpt: ...lidity of the claims asserted against this specific defendant. Plaintiff asserts a cause of action for cancellation of instruments against Defendant Catamount, seeking to cancel Catamount's Trustee's Deed upon Sale ("TDUS") granting it title to the property underlying this conflict. Plaintiff asserts a related declaratory relief cause of acton as well. Title was formerly held by Plaintiff Plaintiff alleges that he has been erroneously deprived of...

Excerpt: ...th argue extensively about the applicability of the discretionary undertaking provision in CCP S 917.9. Both parties largely cite cases which predate the 1958 amendment that created the current version of 917.9, and associated statutes. The concern raised is that the interlocutory judgment compels the sale of the property, and therefore is an order under CCP S 917.4, under which no stay is issued unless the Court sets an undertaking. No party rai...

Excerpt: ...t with due process and have failed to demonstrate that his alleged misconduct is related to the practice of medicine or puts health and safety of others at risk. He also raises other allegations regarding lack of authority or jurisdiction and the need for an oath of allegiance or "fidelity bond," claiming that "Respondents," specifically William Prasifta as Executive Director of the Medical Board of California and deputy attorney general Janssen ...

Excerpt: ...er month for his own use, and (4) hiring personnel without Plaintiff's knowledge or consent — and paying them in cash without following any accounting procedures. The willful failure to comply with a court order constitutes contempt. (In re Grayson (1997) 15 Cal.4th 792, 794.) Contempt requires establishing that a party failed to comply with its order, that the party was aware of the order and had the ability to comply with it, and that the fai...

Excerpt: ... November 4, 2023, and defendant/cross-defendants John Kelly and William Kelly filed supplemental briefs on November 7, 2023 and 13, respectively. Moving party's argument is that, because the facts establishing Judge Pardo's disqualification arose prior to the orders issued by Judge Pardo, those orders are void or voidable, and that the CCP secton 170.3(b)(4) "good cause" provision does not apply to this situaton. John Kelly and William Kelly bot...

Excerpt: ...eglect when she was in the care of Defendants. They allege that after leg surgery, she was admitted to Defendant Summerfield Healthcare Center ("SHC") for recovery, but Defendants' conduct resulted in her developing a Stage Ill pressure ulcer. Decedent was then transferred to Defendant Healdsburg Senior Living Community ("HSLC") where Defendants allowed the wound to worsen, resulting ultimately in her death. Plaintiffs originally named as Defenda...

Excerpt: ... for leave to file a First Amended Petition ("FAP"). There is no opposition. Declaration and Proposed Pleading A moton for leave to amend a complaint must include a copy of the proposed amended complaint and state what allegations are being deleted or added, and "where, by page, paragraph, and line number, the... allegations are located...." California Rule of Court ("CRC") 3.1324(a). The moving party also must provide a declaration that explains...

Excerpt: ...ry judgment or, in the alternative, summary adjudication, which is set for January 19, 2024. Motion Plaintiff moves the Court for leave to amend the complaint and file a First Amended Complaint ("FAC"). Defendants oppose the motion. Declaration and Proposed Pleading A moton for leave to amend a complaint must include a copy of the proposed amended complaint and state what allegations are being deleted or added, and "where, by page, paragraph, and...

Excerpt: ...h, states that Defendant confirmed his identity but that he "tried to refuse service by refusing to take documents and did not state reason for refusal." Mr. ujeh noted, "documents left, seen by subject." In his declaration, Defendant states that on the evening of May 24, 2023, he had returned to his home and was about to leave when he heard a man bellowing from his neighbor's driveway. (Ahlstrom decl., 92.) Defendant asked the man what he needed...

Excerpt: ...d, with Plaintiff's interest in the Tractor recorded. It alleges that Defendant purchased the Tractor from Garton Tractor, Inc. ("Garton") through an installment sales contract (the "Contract") requiring Defendant to make installment payments and giving Garton a security interest in the Tractor. Garton then allegedly assigned and transferred its interest in the Contract and Tractor to Plaintiff. Plaintiff complains that Defendant has failed to ma...

Excerpt: ...the SAC is MOOT based on the Court sustaining the entirety of the demurrer. Procedural History This action arises from a rental agreement between Plaintiff and Defendants of a compact RV and later a separate midsize RV. (SAC, '1 1.) As alleged in the SAC, Plaintiff's home burned down on September 12, 2021, in the Hopkins wildfire, and he was using this RV to temporarily live in while cleanup and repairs were done on his property. (SAC, 1.) Howeve...

Excerpt: ...lmes, which included a manufactured home. Defendant Lauren Berg was the dual agent for the transaction and Defendant Sotheby's was the dual broker. Plaintiffs allege that oral representations were made by Berg and Sotheby's that the manufactured home had been fully inspected and had received necessary permits, a certificate of occupancy, and was ready to be lived in, but that Plaintiffs later learned the manufactured home had not received certain...

Excerpt: ...Motion is provisionally GRANTED. The Complaint The Complaint alleges that Defendants failed to comply with designated California Labor Cade ("LC") provisions during the course of his employment with Defendants, and alleges on information and belief that these defective policies were also in place for other employees. The Complaint contains a single cause of achon under PAGA for civil #naltes resulting from the following labor law violations: i) m...

Excerpt: ...easonable; Approving the Class Representative Service Payments in the amounts of $5ßnm; Approving the Attorneys' Fees in the amount of $393,333.33; Approving the Attorneys' Costs in the amount of $16,019.37; Approving the Settlement Administration Costs in the amount of $18,350m; Certifying the Class for settlement purposes; Finding that Class Members were given adequate notce of the Settlement and, in a reasonable manner, advised of their right...

Excerpt: ...(the "Property") in violation of applicable zoning codes, and filed this action to abate the conditions and uses as well as to recover civil penalties, abatement costs, attorneys' fees, and legal costs. It alleges that Defendants "William J. and Janet M. Freitas" (collectively, "Freitas Defendants") own, operate, possess, and control the Property while Defendant Jason Pierce, referring to himself in his pleadings as Jason Pearce ("Pearce") is the...

Excerpt: ...on. PROCEDURAL HISTORY This achon arises from a property ownership dispute. Clark alleges that she lived with her sister, Seiffert, at 208 Indian Creek Drive, Santa Rosa, California 95409 (the "Property") for a period of roughly nine years, during which time Clark has recently discovered that Seiffert allegedly stole substantial sums of money from Clark while caring for her. (Motion for Leave Memorandum of Points and Authorities ["Motion MPA"I, 2...

Excerpt: ... IRP Fund II Trust 2A; IRP REO II, LLC; and Servis One, Inc. dba BSI Financial Services (all represented by same counsel) obtained an order for summary judgment in their favor. The fourth defendant (Entra Default Solutions) never appeared in the achon and their default was taken on November 29, 2021. On July 28, 2023, defendant IRP REO II, LLC (the property owner) filed and served a CCP section 405.30 motion to expunge the lis pendens and for att...

Excerpt: ...udes a kitchen and living room (the "Common Area"). He alleges that his Room includes a bedroom and bathroom and has a door leading directly into the Common Area, which can also be reached by a door from the outside. However, he complains, the other members of Defendant have bolted and locked both doors to the Common Area and posted a "no trespassing" sign on the outer door to the Common Area, preventing Plaintiff from accessing it. He further co...

Excerpt: ...Proc. ("CCP") S 435. The motion is DENIED. Legal Standards A motion to strike lies where a pleading contains "irrelevant, false, or improper matter[s]" or is "not drawn or filed in conformity with the laws of this state, a court rule, or an order of the court." CCP S 435(b). However, "falsity," must be demonstrated by reference to the pleading itself of judicially noticeable matters, not extraneous facts. See CCP S 437. "Where a written instrumen...

Excerpt: ... asserting rights under FEHA Ultimately, he claims, he was terminated due to his disability and for discriminatory and retaliatory motives. He specifically alleges that Defendant Jay Garcia ("Garcia"), has manager, and Luz Mejia ("Mejia"), his supervisor and also girlfriend of Garcia, committed the illegal conduct. Motion Defendant Thermo moves the court to compel Plaintiff to submit this matter to binding contractual arbitration. It claims that ...

Excerpt: ...iv. Proc. ("CCP") S 435. The motion is DENIED. Legal Standards A motion to strike lies where a pleading contains "irrelevant, false, or improper matter[s]" or is "not drawn or filed in conformity with the laws of this state, a court rule, or an order of the court." CCP S 436(b). However, "falsity," must be demonstrated by reference to the pleading itself of judicially noticeable matters, not extraneous facts. See CCP S 437. A moton to strike is a...

Excerpt: ...ing the complete details of the payment of settlement amounts within the next ten (10) calendar days. The declaration of Gomez, filed January 10, 2023, does not contain the necessary details. The Court reviewed the file and cannot locate another declaration. If Plaintiffs' counsel previously filed a declaration that addresses the concerns listed in this tentative, the Court requests Plaintiffs' counsel contact the Court. Following final approval,...

Excerpt: ...udgment in the amount of $48,013.78. The motion is DENIED. CCP S 664.6(a) provides: "If parties to #nding litigation stipulate, in a writing signed by the parties outside of the presence of the court or orally before the court, for settlement of the case, or part thereof, the court, upon motion, may enter judgment pursuant to the terms of the settlement. If requested by the parties, the court may retain jurisdiction over the parties to enforce th...

Excerpt: ...ffs' complaint is between Plaintiffs and defendant CR Consulting Group ("CRCG"). (FAC, Exhibit A.) The construction license number listed for CRCG is 836482. (Ibid.) It is signed by Cesar Rodriguez ("Rodriguez") on behalf of CRCG. (Ibid.) While there is a space for Paul J. Aguirre, dba, Aguirre Construction Co. to sign, no signature was affixed. (Ibid.) The agreement contains an arbitration clause which states that any controversy or claim arisin...

Excerpt: ...and to deem requests for admissions ("RFAs") admitted under CCP S 2033.280. Defendant has filed a declaration of non-oppositon to all motions. The unopposed Motons to compel are GRANTED. The parties are ORDERED TO APPEAR on the issue of time for compliance. Plaintiff's motion to deem admissions admitted is also APPEARANCES REQUIRED. Defendant shall pay $560 in sanctions to Plaintiff within thirty (30) days of notice of entry of the order on this ...

Excerpt: ..., which the city council ("Council") of City of Petaluma ("Respondent") approved at a final hearing on April 1, 2019, reversing a prior vote of December 3, 2018. Respondent's Planning Commission ("Commission") had approved a CEQA mitgated negative declaration ("MND") and Site Plan and Architectural Review ("SPAR") for the Project in June 2018, but members of Petitioner appealed to Respondent's City Council ("Council"). Petitoner sets forth two ca...

Excerpt: ..., and Defendant's employee on more than one occasion came to the Premises to perform repair work when Plaintiff and her minor children were in the Premises. Amongst other things, the Employee made numerous sexual references to Plaintiff, discussed his sexual relations, and made disparaging remarks about Plaintiff participating in the Voucher Program for Low Income Family in order to lease the Premises. On September 15, 2022, Defendant served Plai...

Excerpt: ... GRANTED. The Complaint The presently 0#rative First Amended Complaint ("Complaint") alleges that Defendants failed to comply with California Labor Code ("LC") provisions during the course of his employment with Defendants, and alleges on information and that these policies were also enforced on other employees. The Complaint contains causes of achon for: (i) failure to pay minimum wages; (ii) failure to pay overtime wages; (iii) failure to provi...

Excerpt: ...vid Spivak of The Spivak Law Firm and Walter L. Haines of United Employees Law Group, PC as Class Counsel; (5) appointing Plaintiff as Class Representative ("Class Representative"); (6) approving the use of the notice procedures and related forms; (7) directing that notice be mailed to the proposed Settlement Class; and (8) scheduling a hearing date for the moton for final approval of the class action settlement and for an award of attorneys' fee...

Excerpt: ..., 2018, they purchased a 2018 Honda Odyssey ("the Vehicle") for which Defendant provided warranties ("the Warranties"), but the Vehicle was defective and, although she brought it to Defendant's authorized repair facility to cure the defects, Defendant failed either to cure the defects or repurchase or replace the vehicle as required under the Warranties. Plaintiff asserts that Defendant's conduct violated the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act ("...

Excerpt: ...is granted. Plaintiff's counsel shall submit a written order consistent with this tentative ruling and in compliance with Rule 3.1312. The Court notes that Defendant has attached hundreds of pages to each of his oppositions without any declaration providing foundation for the documents submitted. There is also no accompanying request for judicial notice of anything that might purportedly be judicially noticeable within these attachments. The Cour...

Excerpt: ...ward as a class, defined as: "All parents, family members, guardians or students in the United States who paid tuition to Defendant Sonoma Academy during the year(s) to 2020 for students who graduated before July 2020." SAC 115. This matter is on calendar for Defendant's demurrer to all causes of action within the Complaint pursuant to Cal. Code Civ. Proc. ("CCP") S 430.10(e) for failure to state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of acton. D...

Excerpt: ... conducting proceedings to revoke his license based on a coerced guilty plea to the crime of tax evasion. He contends that Respondents have failed to act with due process and have failed to demonstrate that his alleged misconduct is related to the practice of medicine or puts health and safety of others at risk. He also raises other allegations regarding lack of authority or jurisdiction and the need for an oath of allegiance or "fidelity bond," ...

Excerpt: ...tiffs") on the grounds that it fails to state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action and is uncertain. Defendants Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Company ("MassMutual") and MML Investors Services, LLC ("MML") join the demurrer. The demurrer is OVERRULED. The FAC alleges that the Romans are insurance agents/producers/brokers with MML and MassMutual. (FAC, 926.) As early as 2010, in an effort to provide for the health and well-being o...

Excerpt: ...of $1,560.00 for each motion. Plaintiff's counsel shall submit a written order for each motion consistent with this tentative ruling. Due to the lack of opposition, compliance with Rule 3.1312 is excused. Request for Production of Documents A motion to compel further responses to a request for production of documents must "set forth specific facts showing 'good cause' justifying the discovery sought by the demand." (CCP S 2031.310(b)(1).) Absent ...

Excerpt: ...scencion Roman ("Roman") caused an automobile accident on November 2, 2019, which caused Plaintiff serious injuries and which required numerous surgeries. (FAC, 97.) At the time of the accident, Roman was insured by Encompass with a $50,000 per person, $100,000 per accident insurance policy ("the Policy"). (FAC, 98.) On June 25, 2020, Plaintiff made a demand to Encompass, through claims adjustor Maasberg, for payment of the $50,000 limit of the P...

Excerpt: ...) S 2025.610 to compel subsequent deposition. The Motion is GRANTED in part and DENIED in part. Goveming Law Natural persons, including parties to the action, may not be deposed more than once without a court order based on a show-ng of cause. CCP S 2025.610(a), (b); see Fairmont Ins. Co. v. Sup.Ct. (Stende") 22 cal.4th 245, 254. A witness, including a witness specified in subdivision (b) of Section 1987, is not obliged to attend as a witness bef...

Excerpt: ...arising initially out alleged violations of the Court's orders in another case, SCV-265225. This matter is on calendar for demurrers to all causes of action within the SAC by TRVFD, the County and Thompson pursuant to Cal. Code Civ. Proc. ("CCP") S 430.10(e) for failure to state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action, that there is another action proceeding between the same parties, and for misjoinder of parties. The Demurrer is SUSTAIN...

Excerpt: ...ceive an opportunity to to it. Plaintiff seeks an order com#lling Defendant to turn over complete copies of the hard drives of Defendant's personal computer devices. Plaintiff alleges that, while Defendant Samuel Biasi was working as the general manager of Marr B. Olsen, Inc. (hereafter MBO), he transmitted MBO business data to his devices for use in establishing a competing business. Defendant objected to Plaintiff receiving unfettered access to...

Excerpt: ...ress, menace (extortion), and conspiracy (the "Complaint"). Defendant filed a special Anti-SLAPP motion to strike pursuant to Code Civil of Procedure ("CCP") S 425.16 ("the Motion to Strike"). The Moton to Strike was granted by this Court on April 13, 2022, ("Order") and plaintffs appealed. While the appeal was pending, this court granted Defendant's Motion for Attorneys' Fees and Costs based on CCP 5425.16 and the court's Order granting the Moti...

Excerpt: ...osa, California, with causes of action for: 1) wrongful foreclosure; 2) cancellation of instrument; 3) quiet title; 4) violation of Civ. Code S 2924f; 5) violation of Civ. Code S 2923.5; and 6) violation of Business and Professions Code S 17200 et. seq. This matter is on calendar for PLM's demurrer to all causes of acton within the Complaint pursuant to CCP S 430.10(e) for failure to state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action. Plainti...

Excerpt: ...stained with leave to amend as to Jane Does #3, #6, and #7's third cause of action against Defendant; 4. The Demurrer is sustained with leave to amend as to Jane Does #5 and #7's fourth cause of action against Defendant; 5. The Demurrer is sustained with leave to amend as to Jane Does #5 and #7's fifth cause of action against Defendant; 6. The Demurrer is sustained with leave to amend as to Jane Does #1, #2, #3, #5, and #7's eighth cause of actio...

Excerpt: ...complaint on July 25, 2022, Plaintiff filed of service ("POS") for the summons and complaint on January 19, 2023. The POS shows that she served Defendant at its business location, 3621 Copperhill Lane, Santa Rosa, by personally serving them on one Kyle Abe ("Abe") at Defendant's address on July 25, 2022. On January 25, 2023, Plaintiff obtained the default of Defendant. Defendant, appearing as Cream's Dismantling, Inc., erroneously sued as "Cream'...

Excerpt: ...OT given the sustaining of the demurrer to the Fourth and Fifth Causes of Acton. Defendants' counsel shall submit a written order consistent with this tentative ruling and in compliance with Rule 3.1312. Standard on Demurrer A demurrer tests whether the complaint sufficiently states a valid cause of action. (Hahn v. Merda 147 Cal.App.4th 740, 747.) Complaints are read as a whole, in context and are liberally construed. (Blank v. Kirwan (1985) 39 ...

Excerpt: ...147 Cal.App.4th 740, 747.) Complaints are read as a whole, in context and are liberally construed. (Blank v. Kirwan (1985) 39 cal.3d 311, 318; see also, stevens v. superiorcourt (1999) 75 cal.App.4th 594, 601.) In reviewing the suffciency of a complaint, courts accept as true all material facts properly pleaded, but not contentions, deductions, or conclusions of fact or law, or the construction of instruments pleaded, or facts impossible in law. ...

Excerpt: ...exity and likely duration of further litigation, the risk of maintaining class action status through trial, the amount offered in settlement, the extent of discovery completed and stage of the proceedings, the experience and views of counsel, the presence of a governmental participant, and the reaction of the class members to the proposed settlement." (Kullar v. Foot Locker Retail, Inc. (2008) 158 Cal.App.4th 116, 128, citing Dunk v. Ford Motor c...

Excerpt: ...r Defendant's potential exposure. The court requires this in order to make a final determination regarding whether the Settlement as a whole is fair and reasonable in this regard. In all other respects, the court finds the information and terms of the Settlement to be fair and reasonable for the purposes of this hearing and finds no potential inadequacies at this time. Facts and History Plaintiff Ricardo Perez Ruelas ("Perez") in this action, SCV...

Excerpt: ...Iac"). Or, as another alternative, ELCA requests an order compelling Codac to produce all responsive documents. The motion is DENIED. However, the parties are ordered to meet and confer to appropriately narrow the scope of the records sought and, if necessary, consider an appropriate protective order. The motion is DENIED Plaintiff's complaint alleges that she was a victm of childhood sexual assault and abuse that occurred in Rohnert Park from 19...

Excerpt: ...story Plaintiff complains that Defendants negligently, and in breach of a contract, allowed a dog to run free on the WTBar Ranch at 156 San Antonio Road, Petaluma (the "Premises"), where Plaintiff was boarding horses, thereby allowng the dog to attack and scare Plaintiff's horses. She alleges that she had entered into a contract (the "Contract") with Defendant Barbara Tognalda ("Barbara") by which Plaintiff paid "Defendants" $200 a month in retur...

Excerpt: ...s and History Alleging that he owns and resides on residential real property at 12097 Ramsey Road, Sebastopol, CA (the "Property") and obtained a loan (the "Loan") secured with a Deed of Trust (the "DOT") against the Property, Plaintiff complains that Defendants have improperly attempted to foreclose against the Property. Among other things, he alleges that he submitted a complete application to modify the Loan (the "Application"), but Defendants...

Excerpt: ...ions to Strike A motion to strike lies where a pleading contains "irrelevant, false, or improper matter[s]" or is "not drawn or filed in conformity with the laws of this state, a court rule, or an order of the court." CCP S 435(b). However, "falsity," must be demonstrated by reference to the pleading itself of judicially noticeable matters, not extraneous facts. See CCP S 437. A motion to strike is also properly directed to unauthorized claims fo...

Excerpt: ...tant complaint against Defendant on May 8, 2023. Moving Defendant was personally served on May 25, 2023. Plaintiff requested entry of default on August 30, 2023, which was granted against Defendant. Defendant filed the instant motion to set aside the default on September 19, 2023. Plaintiff has filed no opposition to the motion. Governing Law "The court may, upon any terms as may be just, relieve a party or his or her legal representative from a ...

Excerpt: ...oth Fire and Hunsaker. Evidentiary and Procedural Issues A. Citations The Court previously raised the issue that Plaintiff c:ited Bagdadi v. Go Daddy Software, Inc. (2CM) 154 Cal.App.4th 1176 and Anderson v. Continental Insurance, Co. (1992) 6 Cal.App.4th 1659, in the motions. When the Court sought to get clarification as to these decisions, and whether they somehow countermand the decisions in R & B Auto Center, Inc. v. Farmers Group, Inc. (2W6)...

Excerpt: ...Hahn v. Merda (2007) 147 Cal.App.4th 740, 747.) Complaints are read as a whole, in context and are liberally construed. (Blank v. Kirwan (1985) 39 cal.3d 311, 318; see also, stevens v. superior court (1999) 75 cal.App.4th 594, 601.) In reviewing the sufficiency of a complaint, courts accept as true all material facts properly pleaded, but not contentions, deductions, or conclusions of fact or law, or the construction of instruments pleaded, or fa...

Excerpt: ...the complaint sufficiently states a valid cause of action. (Hahn v. Merda 147 Cal.App.4th 740, 747.) Complaints are read as a whole, in context and are liberally construed. (Blank v. Kirwan (1985) 39 cal.3d 311, 318; see also, Stevens v. superior court (1999) 75 cal.App.4th 594, 601.) In reviewing the sufficiency of a complaint, courts accept as true all material facts properly pleaded, but not contentions, deductions, or conclusions of fact or l...

Excerpt: ..., which are part of the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act ("CMIA"). This matter is on calendar for Defendants' demurrer to all causes of acton within the Complaint pursuant to CCP S 430.10(e) for failure to state facts sufficient to consttute a cause of action. The Demurrer is SUSTAINED with leave to amend. Legal Standards A. Demurrers Generally A demurrer can be used only to challenge defects that appear on the face of the pleading unde...

Excerpt: ...rgument that Petitioner must have sought costs with the arbitrator and therefore cannot now seek them in these judicial proceedings. While these cases did find that costs should have been sought with the arbitrator, these cases also involved "broad" arbitration agreements which did not limit the arbitrator's power in any way." If the parties' agreement does 'not limit the issues to be resolved through arbitration, the issue of [a party's] entitle...

Excerpt: ...Cal.4th 540, 643 ["We conclude that the FEHA, like similar federal statutes, allows persons to sue and hold liable their employers, but not individuals. Our conclusion also applies to common law actions for wrongful discharge."] Any amended pleading shall be filed not later than 10 court days after service of notice of an order on this motion. Given the grant of leave to amend, the trial date of October 13, 2023, is VACATED. The case is scheduled...

Excerpt: ...Material Fact "UMF" 4-5,9.) Defendant Ben Zabinsky"s property is one of these parcels. (Ibid.) Plaintiffs' property is another of the parcels. (Ibid.) The portion of land in front of the parcels that is now at issue was owned by the former owners of all of the parcels of land, Mr. and Mrs. Estrella. (UMF 72.) Plaintiffs now own the portion of the easement that is directly in front of Defendant's property. (UMF 72.) The Estrellas sold what is now ...

Excerpt: ...ct, and that consolidation would avoid unnecessary costs, delays, duplication of proof, and inconsistent rulings. Specifically, both of these cases arise from the same incident that occurred on February 22, 2019, wherein plaintiff Dorian Gabriel Guerrero ("Guerrero") sustained an industrial injury from a concrete hose as a result of the alleged negligence of defendants Kyle David Shepherd, Gallagher Construction, Inc., William Gallagher, and Craf...

Excerpt: ...ory fraud (the "FAC"). This matter is on calendar for Defendant's demurrer to the seventh cause of action within the FAC pursuant to Cal. Code Civ. Proc. ("CCP") S 430.10(e) for failure to state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of achon and CCP S 430.10(f) for uncertainty. Defendant's demurrer to Plaintiff's First Amended Complaint is OVERRULED. Governing Law A. Standard on Demurrer A demurrer can be used only to challenge defects that appe...

Excerpt: ... dismissal. The motion is DENIED. Governing Law A new trial is a re-examination of an issue of fact in the same court after a trial and decision by a jury, court, or referee." CCP S 656. However, "[tlhe right to a new trial is purely statutory, and a motion for a new trial can be granted only on one of the grounds enumerated in the statute." Fomco, Inc. u Joe Maggio, Inc. (1961) 55 cal.2d 162, 166. The verdict may be vacated and any other decisio...

Excerpt: ...equests for Admissions, Set One ("RFAs"). Plaintiff subsequently moved the court to order the RFAs, be deemed admitted on the basis that Defendant had failed to respond. The court granted the motion in full after the hearing of January 6, 2023. Motion Plaintiff moves the court for judgment on the pleadings in it favor on its complaint against Defendant. It argues that the court deemed the RFAs admitted and that these demonstrate that there is no ...

Excerpt: ...ow Cause re Dismissal for lack of prosecution on December 15, 2022. The OSC hearing was set for February 16, 2023. Plaintiff nor their counsel appeared at the February 16, 2023 hearing. The case was dismissed as a result of Plaintiff's non-appearance. This motion was filed August 7, 2023. The parties signed a stipulation settling the matter in October of 2022. Governing Law "The court may, upon any terms as may be just, relieve a party or his or ...

Excerpt: ...intiffs' request for an Order to Show Cause re: Contempt for violations of court orders, and for TRVFD's request to dissolve the preliminary injunction issued August 4, 2021. As to the Contempt, the matter is APPEARANCES REQUIRED. The motion to dissolve the preliminary injunction is DENIED. Underlying Facts Plaintiffs' causes of action are predicated on allegations of violations of the use Permit issued for TRVFD's property adjoining the property...

Excerpt: ...plitter which caused Plaintiff's injury. Defendant's undisputed Material Facts ("DUMF") '1 1. Defendant did not have any responsibility for creation of the wood splitter, or its transition into the market place. DUMF '1 3-5. Defendant borrowed the wood splitter. DUMF '12. The Burdens on Summary Judgment and Adjudication A. Generally Summary adjudication "shall be granted if all the papers submitted show that there is no triable issue as to any ma...

Excerpt: ...he required information regarding the other parent and properly serve sufficient notice on the other parent, or demonstrate either that the other parent is not living, or that Petitioner is unable to identify or locate the other parent after making a reasonably diligent effort to do so. Petitioner must provide evidence and explanation suffcient to satisfy these requirements. If Petitioner does not provide the required information or documentation...

Excerpt: ...ery regarding California's jurisdiction over VADO and Orangeworks. Plaintiff Smashmallow LLC ("Smashmallow") filed this complaint against Orangeworks and VADO alleging causes of action for Actual Fraudulent Transfer and for Tortious Interference. Orangeworks is the parent company of Tanis Food Tech 8M. ("Tanis"). (Complaint, 95.) On October 11, 2022, Tanis and Orangeworks were acquired by VADO, a Dutch private equity firm. (ibid.) Smashmallow has...

Excerpt: ...s and Recreation, through which job she became a member of the California Public Employees' Retrement System ("CalPERS"). (Petition, Exhibit A, pg. 2, 1; Administrative Record ["AR"], AR000004.) At the time, Decedent's registered domestic partner was real party in interest, Donna Starr ("Starr"). (Petition, at Exhibit A, pg. 2, 2; AR, AR000005.) Decedent listed Starr as a beneficiary when she rebred in 2015 and started receiving a monthly retirem...

Excerpt: ...is without prejudice as this defect may be readily cured and, while not a best practice, the law does not prohibit bringing a motion for sanctions separately from the underlying motion to compel. (London v. Dri-Honing Corp. (2Cu) 117 Cal.App.4th 999, ICOS.) Plaintiff's counsel shall submit a written order consistent with this motion and in compliance with Rule 3.1312. A motion to compel further responses to a request for production of documents m...

Excerpt: ...ional interference with economic relations; 8) intentional infliction of emotional distress; 9) declaratory relief; 10) quiet title; and 11) injunctive relief. This matter is on calendar for the moton by Flint for summary judgment of the SAC or in the alternative adjudication pursuant to Cal. Code Civ. Proc. ("CCP") S 437(c). Summary judgment is DENIED. Summary adjudication is GRANTED in part and DENIED in part. l. Evidentiary and Pleading Issues...

Excerpt: ... the notces served on Plaintiff It must also serve Plaintiff by proper means, not electronically unless it shows that Plaintiff has affrmatively agreed to electronic service. Facts and History Plaintiff complains that Defendant, who had previously towed her motorhome (the "Motorhome"), unlawfully and without her permission or notice to her, dismantled the Motorhome with all of her possessions inside. She seeks damages for the loss of the Motorhom...

Excerpt: ...ees and class representative enhancements. The Motions are GRANTED. Applicable A. Fairness of Settlement Standards After preliminary approval, the Court determines whether a class action settlement is fair, adequate and reasonable in a final hearing, often referred to as a "fairness hearing." Cal. R. Ct. 3.769(g); see also Dunk v. Ford Motor Co. (1996) 48 Cal.App.4th 1794, 1801. The purpose of this requirement is "the protection of those class me...

Excerpt: ...mplaint for fraud (See Declaration of Amin Kazemini ["Kazemini Decl."l, Exhibit A, the "Cross-complaint"), as during discovery Plaintiff produced two seemingly conflicting copies of the underlying lease. Moving Defendant alleges that the Plaintiff has created a fraudulent copy. Plaintiff does not attach a copy of the Lease to the Complaint. Moving Defendant argues that he should be allowed to file the cross-complaint as it is compulsory. l. Le I ...

Excerpt: ...e such that it allowed an uneven roadway to exist. Plaintiff alleges that she fell due to the uneven roadway and sustained severe and permanent injuries. Two causes of action are alleged: one for negligence and one for premises liability. Plaintiff filed a Claim Against The City of Petaluma on August 26, 2021 ("the Claim") which states that Plaintiff was lawfully riding a skateboard on Turtle Creek Lane when the wheel of her skateboard caught on ...

Excerpt: ...ached the contract by failing to pay the amount owed. Plaintiff filed this action to collect the debt, allegedly $2,312.27, plus costs, legal fees, and interest. Defendants failed to appear, so Plaintiff took their default on January 3, 2023, and obtained a default judgment against them on March 6, 2023, for $3,047.15. Post-Jud nt Discove Plaintiff served Defendants by mail with post-judgment discovery on March 27, 2023; the discovery included on...

Excerpt: ...this motion, which this court continued due to inadequate notice, the moving party filed only an unsigned, incomplete proposed order, with proof of service. Accordingly, nothing shows that Plaintiff was served with, or otherwise received, notice of the hearing. Prior to the new hearing date, the moving party, must file and serve complete, sufficient proof of service at least 10 court days prior to the new hearing, showing service of a notice of t...

Excerpt: ...er with KFH and Health Plan, "Defendants"), and Does 1-50, arising out of Defendants' care of Decedent. This matter is on calendar for the petition by the Defendants to compel arbitration pursuant to Cal. Code Civ. Proc. ("CCP") S 1281.2. Defendants' petition to compel arbitration and stay proceedings is DENIED. l. Facts and Procedure The Decedent signed an "Enrollment Application" in April of 2004. See Woods Declaration in Support ("Woods Decl."...

Excerpt: ... violated building codes. As a result, Plaintiff fell down the stairway and sustained serious injuries. In support of his request for punitive damages, Plaintiffs FAC alleges that Defendants were aware of the dangerous and defective condition of the stairway prior to Plaintiff's fall, that Defendants knew that previous individuals had fallen down the stairway, that several individuals had requested Defendants repair the stairway, and that Defenda...

Excerpt: ...fying that that each party shall bear its own attorney's fees and costs. Defendants cite Zamora v. Clayborn Contracting Grp., Inc. (2002) 28 Cal.4th 249, 258 in support of the argument that the mistake made was an excusable mistake that a reasonably prudent person under the same circumstances would have made. However, Zamora is not factually on point and Plaintiff has cited to two cases which specifically address the omission of an attorney's fee...

Excerpt: ...Plaintiff has had sufficient notce and opportunity to be heard. Accordingly, the court issues an order to show cause why the court should not dismiss this action and sets this matter on the law and motion calendar in this department, at 3:00 p.m., on October 25, 2023. Defendants must serve Plaintiff again with the moving papers as well as Order to Show Cause and notice of the new hearing at least 21 calendar days prior to the hearing and must fil...

Excerpt: ...fendant's authorized repair facility to cure the defects, Defendant failed either to cure the defects or repurchase or replace the vehicle as required under the Warranties. Plaintiff asserts that Defendant's conduct violated the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act ("Song-Beverly") at Civil Code ("CC") section 1790, et seq. Plaintiff filed a Mohon to Compel Further Responses to Plaintiff's Requests for Production of Documents, Set One which this co...

Excerpt: ... party to the action or an officer, director, managing agent, or employee of a party, or a person designated by an organization that is a party under Section 2025.230, without having served a valid objection under Section 2025.410, fails to appear for examination, or to proceed with it, or to produce for inspection any document or tangible thing described in the deposition notice, the party giving the notice may move for an order compelling the d...

Excerpt: ... between Pe
Ÿ
Ÿoner and Respondent Priya Latchman contains an agreement to arbitrate her underinsured motorist claims but does not provide a method for appoin
Ÿng a neutral arbitrator. The par
Ÿes cannot agree on a neutral arbitrator. Pe
Ÿ
Ÿoner has provided a list of Þve candidates. CCP sec
Ÿon 1281.2 provides that on pe
Ÿ
Ÿon of a party a trial court must order the par
Ÿes to arbitra
Ÿon where it Þnds a wri
©en agreement exists be...

Excerpt: ...lthough Youngs performed, Defendants breached the contract by failing to pay the amount owed. Plaintiff filed this action to collect the debt, allegedly $1,169.85, plus costs, legal fees, and interest. Defendants failed to appear so Plaintiff took their default on February 14, 2023 and obtained a default judgment against them on March 22, 2023 for $1,867.31. Post-Jud nt Discove Plaintiff served Defendants by mail with post-judgment discovery on A...